WSU Lexicon: Equities
Method of Comparables
The method of comparables is a relative valuation approach that estimates a stock's value by applying a multiple observed for similar companies or a benchmark, such as P/E, P/B, P/S or EV/EBITDA, to the subject firm's own earnings, book value, sales or EBITDA.
It contrasts with the method based on forecasted fundamentals, which derives a justified multiple from a discounted cash flow model.
The entry
Applying a peer multiple to estimate value
The analyst first assembles a comparable set: firms in the same industry with similar size, growth prospects, risk, capital structure and accounting conventions. The chosen multiple is computed for each peer, then summarised with a central measure such as the median, mean or harmonic mean. The subject company's multiple is compared with that benchmark, or the benchmark multiple is multiplied by the subject's fundamental to produce an implied value.
The type of multiple determines what the result represents. A price multiple such as P/E, multiplied by earnings per share, yields an implied value per share. An enterprise multiple such as EV/EBITDA, multiplied by EBITDA, yields implied enterprise value, from which net debt, preferred stock and noncontrolling interests are deducted to reach equity value.
The entry
The law of one price and the limits of relative pricing
The economic rationale is the law of one price: assets offering essentially the same cash flows and risk should trade at the same price. If two firms are truly comparable, a meaningful gap in their multiples signals that one is relatively mispriced. The approach is popular because it relies on observable market prices, needs fewer forecasts than a discounted cash flow model and is easy to communicate to clients and committees.
The central weakness is that it accepts the market's pricing of the peer group as correct. It cannot detect when an entire sector is mispriced. Real peers also differ in growth, risk and profitability, so analysts adjust for these differences, for example by examining the PEG ratio or explaining why a premium or discount is warranted, rather than treating any gap as an opportunity.
The entry
Choosing the benchmark and the multiple
Benchmarks range from a handpicked set of close competitors, to an industry or sector median, to a broad equity index, to the company's own historical average multiple. Each answers a different question: whether the stock is cheap against rivals, against the market, or against its own past.
The multiple should suit the business. P/E fits mature, consistently profitable firms. P/B suits banks and other financials whose assets are carried near market value. P/S is useful for early-stage or loss-making companies where earnings are negative. EV/EBITDA allows comparison of firms with different leverage, tax positions and depreciation policies. Numerator and denominator must be consistent: enterprise value pairs with a pre-interest measure such as EBITDA, while equity price pairs with a post-interest measure such as net income.
The entry
What candidates must be able to do with comparables
Candidates should be able to calculate a benchmark multiple from peer data, compute an implied share price or enterprise value, and state whether the subject appears relatively overvalued or undervalued. Equally important is the qualitative step: identifying fundamental reasons, such as slower growth, higher risk or lower return on equity, that could justify a multiple differing from the peer average.
Candidates should also recognise practical pitfalls. Trailing and forward multiples must not be mixed within one comparison. Nonrecurring items, differences between IFRS and US GAAP, and cyclical earnings peaks or troughs can distort ratios. Negative earnings make P/E meaningless, which is why earnings yield or an alternative multiple is used. Finally, the result is a relative judgement, not an estimate of intrinsic value.
Common trap
“A stock trading at a lower P/E than its peer median is undervalued and should rise in price.”
The method establishes only relative value. If the whole peer group is overpriced, a stock that looks cheap against it can still be overvalued in absolute terms. A discount may also be justified by lower expected growth, higher risk or weaker earnings quality.
In practice
Relative cheapness during the 2000 technology bubble
In early 2000 many technology stocks looked inexpensive against sector peers trading at extreme multiples. When the Nasdaq Composite fell roughly 78% from its March 2000 peak to its October 2002 low, the relatively cheap names fell alongside the rest of the group.
Candidates ask
Questions on this term
- How does the method of comparables differ from the method based on forecasted fundamentals?Comparables benchmarks a multiple against peers or the market and measures relative value. The fundamentals method derives a justified multiple from growth, risk and payout assumptions, linking it to intrinsic value.
- Should I use the mean or the median multiple of the peer group?The median is usually preferred because a single outlier, such as a peer with depressed earnings and an inflated P/E, can pull the arithmetic mean far from the typical value. The harmonic mean is another option for ratios like P/E because it gives less weight to very high multiples. Reporting more than one measure shows how sensitive the conclusion is to the choice.
- When is EV/EBITDA a better comparables multiple than P/E?EV/EBITDA is preferable when peers differ significantly in leverage, because enterprise value captures both debt and equity and EBITDA is measured before interest. It also neutralises differences in depreciation policy and tax rates, and it often remains positive when net income is negative. P/E remains a natural choice for mature, similarly financed, consistently profitable firms.
See also
Related entries
- Enterprise ValueEnterprise value is the total market value of a company's operating business, independent of how it is financed.
- EV/EBITDAEV/EBITDA is a valuation multiple that divides enterprise value by earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortisation.
- Price-to-Book RatioThe price-to-book ratio divides market price per share by book value of equity per share, comparing what investors pay to the accounting net asset value the firm reports.
- Price-to-Earnings RatioThe price-to-earnings ratio divides a company's share price by its earnings per share, showing what investors pay for each unit of earnings.
One entry from the WSU Lexicon every day. Browse the full archive.